Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

Last post 07-30-2008 1:05 AM by rosebud07. 68 replies.
Page 1 of 5 (69 items) 1 2 3 4 5 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 07-10-2008 1:40 AM

    Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    It may not be cool to post here about the CNBC Million contest, but wouldn’t it be cooler if a Survivor could nab one of the prizes?  Don’t worry, WSS, this will always be my home game, though I’ve got to share my story.

     

    First, congrats to Corky on an outstanding run she’s put together.  She has a few portfolios that have done very well, including one that had reached higher than 400th place.  That’s simply outstanding out of 750,000 portfolios total.  With just over a week to go, she still has a shot.  Anybody else?

     

    For those who don’t know, CNBC offers an annual contest with a boatload of prize money.  This year it’s a 10-week game with the winner getting a $500,000 prize, and the next five finishers taking home $50,000 and up.  Each entrant gets five portfolios.

     

    One of my portfolios began doing quite well from the start, then just kept on going.  A simple portfolio, just four coal stocks.  Well, about three weeks in, I hit the leaderboard in 24th place.  Once I peeled myself off the ceiling, I kept watching things continue up from there.  A few days later I landed in a money position, 6th place.  I ended up bouncing around between 6th and 2nd place for the next 3-4 weeks.  With ¾ of a million other portfolios out there, I knew this was a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

     

    So what to do? Stick with the strategy that got me there?  Or take profits and get off before it hits a brick wall?  I decided to keep riding the wave.  After all, there were only about two more weeks to go, and the signs looked positive.  And then it crashed.  Last Wednesday, coal stocks suddenly fell 15-20%, out of nowhere.  I emerged in about 200th place with a ton of real estate between the leaderboard and me.

     

    I’m holding out for a coal rebound, and so far it’s taken me back to 67th place with seven sessions to go.  It’s still possible to get back in the race with a good run.  There’s still a chance.  Either way, it’s been a real thrill.  (Though WSS is still a better game!)

     

    Thanks, Survivors, for sending any good vibes my way.  I could really use it!  And go Corky!

  • 07-10-2008 9:25 AM In reply to

    • Bogle
    • Not Ranked
    • Joined on 09-08-2007
    • Posts 4

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    good luck! I looked into the CNBC game but its a bit simplified for my taste. No ETFs, no shorting etc etc. It's kind of a ridiculous tournament in that obviously the best strategy is to start each portfolio with just 4 smallcaps and cross your fingers. I imagine thats what everyone is doing. with 5 portfolios there's no incentive to diversify. Some people have probably signed up 50 portfolios under every family member with just 4 stocks in each. It seems more like a lottery than a stock trading game.
  • 07-10-2008 9:34 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    Congrats man on the CNBC performance. I'd probably quit now and just hope you coast into a good place :) Market is too volatile for my likings! 

  • 07-10-2008 9:38 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    Ditto

  • 07-10-2008 9:38 PM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

     

    Wow, great story Gomaxgo. It looks like this CNBC game has you hooked. Is it the prize money or the competition of 750 000? You seem always be so close to grab the trophy and then stumble at the finish line. However, as long you follow your own conviction then your day will come to win big. I for one have no doubts in your ability.

    Perhaps some of our players here at WSS, like corky will soon be, part of the CNBC leader-board. Good luck my friend, it seems coal is still your best bet to the top!

    Happy trading…

  • 07-11-2008 3:08 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    Way to go, gomaxgo!  Good luck, and I hope you come out on top!  I don't know how you find the time to do both.  I'm finding it tough enough to keep up with one game ;-).

  • 07-12-2008 1:30 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    Thanks, all.  Hey, I'm back on the leaderboard again at #20.  Coal's been finding its legs again.  Still got a shot.  What a blast to have a chance at this point.

    Bogle, you're right, "lottery" is a good word for it.  WSS offers a much more comprehensive and realistic game that calls for more strategy and ability.  But what a rush with lottery-type winnings on the line.  Luego, you remember well my angst at trying to hold the lead in the last WSS round.  Here we go again.  This is actually the third contest this year where I've been in the money late in the game, only to tail off.  Guess that's what happens when you're a trend player and stick with the trend too long.

    Just one week to go.  I'll report back on how things go....

  • 07-12-2008 8:50 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    You are the best, maestro. I knew it through a bunch of posts and extraordinary performances in the last contest. Like Luego says, "you seem always be so close to grab the trophy."

    It's interesting to see what next week will bring to us. It's been a tale of two markets for a while: a commodity bull and a dismal bear of the rest of the markets. I believe the markets are at the cross road now: the crude oil futures hit another all time high on Friday and the mess of mortgages and banking systems are at the crux of explosion represented by FNM and FRE. The markets overall are extremely oversold at the key support levels. Add earnings report and options expiration to the mix. It's really hard to tell where the ball will bounce.

    You made us at WSS proud. Wish you and Corky best of luck

  • 07-12-2008 9:28 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    I know you can do it....I have complete confidence in you!!!

  • 07-12-2008 9:31 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    That would be TOO COOL!

  • 07-14-2008 12:11 PM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    That game is such a piece of ****. I got so disgusted, i own a mac osx and really didn't matter the browser i used (camino) I was in the top 5% and nailed the flr earnings and made a small fortune and then started to notice that when i exit a position, it wouldn't register right away but at the end of day or whatever erasing all gains. No real time quotes and what a user unfriendly game. Thought it would be fun, but just pissed me off. Is there something i could have done different?
  • 07-14-2008 12:12 PM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    CNBC PORTFOLIO CHALLENGE SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • 07-14-2008 1:40 PM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

     yeah, it could happen

  • 07-14-2008 2:14 PM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    Wow, great job Gomaxgo and corky!!

  • 07-15-2008 2:25 AM In reply to

    Re: Will a Survivor win at CNBC?

    Thanks, everyone.  I really appreciate the encouragement!  I gained a few more spots today; now up to #15.  Just four days left and another nine spots to go.  Elephant Man: I hear where you're coming from.  I learned the hard way about how CNBC handles trades.  Yes, it processes them at the end of the session.  I lost a $100,000 profit one day that I thought I had earned, only to find out that the picks hadn't yet processed.  That's one of the reasons for my citing WSS as the superior game (one of many). 

Page 1 of 5 (69 items) 1 2 3 4 5 Next >